Head to head

Compare tonneau covers

49 side-by-side comparisons across 22 covers — security, weather sealing, bed access, material, weight and warranty, each with a plain verdict rather than a scoreboard.

Hard folding compared

Like against like — same cover type, so the comparison is about execution.

BAKFlip F1 vs BAKFlip MX4 $$$ vs $$$ BAKFlip F1 vs Extang Solid Fold ALX $$$ vs $$$ BAKFlip F1 vs Rough Country Hard Tri-Fold $$$ vs $ BAKFlip F1 vs UnderCover Flex $$$ vs $$ BAKFlip MX4 vs Extang Solid Fold ALX $$$ vs $$$ BAKFlip MX4 vs Rough Country Hard Tri-Fold $$$ vs $ BAKFlip MX4 vs UnderCover Flex $$$ vs $$ Extang Solid Fold ALX vs Rough Country Hard Tri-Fold $$$ vs $ Extang Solid Fold ALX vs UnderCover Flex $$$ vs $$ Rough Country Hard Tri-Fold vs UnderCover Flex $ vs $$

Tri-fold compared

Like against like — same cover type, so the comparison is about execution.

Extang Trifecta 2.0 vs Gator ETX Tri-Fold $$ vs $ Extang Trifecta 2.0 vs TonnoPro Tri-Fold $$ vs $ Extang Trifecta 2.0 vs Tyger Auto T3 $$ vs $ Gator ETX Tri-Fold vs TonnoPro Tri-Fold $ vs $ Gator ETX Tri-Fold vs Tyger Auto T3 $ vs $ TonnoPro Tri-Fold vs Tyger Auto T3 $ vs $

Soft roll-up compared

Like against like — same cover type, so the comparison is about execution.

Access Original Roll-Up vs Gator ETX Roll-Up $$ vs $ Access Original Roll-Up vs TruXedo Lo Pro $$ vs $$ Access Original Roll-Up vs TruXedo TruXport $$ vs $ Access Original Roll-Up vs Tyger T1 Soft Roll-Up $$ vs $ Gator ETX Roll-Up vs TruXedo Lo Pro $ vs $$ Gator ETX Roll-Up vs TruXedo TruXport $ vs $ Gator ETX Roll-Up vs Tyger T1 Soft Roll-Up $ vs $ TruXedo Lo Pro vs TruXedo TruXport $$ vs $ TruXedo Lo Pro vs Tyger T1 Soft Roll-Up $$ vs $ TruXedo TruXport vs Tyger T1 Soft Roll-Up $ vs $

Hard roll-up compared

Like against like — same cover type, so the comparison is about execution.

BAK Revolver X4s vs TruXedo Sentry CT $$ vs $$

Retractable compared

Like against like — same cover type, so the comparison is about execution.

Retrax PRO XR vs RetraxONE MX $$$ vs $$$ Retrax PRO XR vs Roll-N-Lock A-Series $$$ vs $$$ Retrax PRO XR vs Roll-N-Lock M-Series $$$ vs $$$ RetraxONE MX vs Roll-N-Lock A-Series $$$ vs $$$ RetraxONE MX vs Roll-N-Lock M-Series $$$ vs $$$ Roll-N-Lock A-Series vs Roll-N-Lock M-Series $$$ vs $$$

Hinged compared

Like against like — same cover type, so the comparison is about execution.

UnderCover Classic vs UnderCover Elite LX $$ vs $$$

Across cover types

The strongest cover of each type against the strongest of another — for when you are still deciding what kind of cover you want.

Access Original Roll-Up vs BAK Revolver X4s Soft roll-up vs Hard roll-up Access Original Roll-Up vs BAKFlip F1 Soft roll-up vs Hard folding Access Original Roll-Up vs Extang Trifecta 2.0 Soft roll-up vs Tri-fold Access Original Roll-Up vs Retrax PRO XR Soft roll-up vs Retractable Access Original Roll-Up vs UnderCover Classic Soft roll-up vs Hinged BAK Revolver X4s vs BAKFlip F1 Hard roll-up vs Hard folding BAK Revolver X4s vs Extang Trifecta 2.0 Hard roll-up vs Tri-fold BAK Revolver X4s vs Retrax PRO XR Hard roll-up vs Retractable BAK Revolver X4s vs UnderCover Classic Hard roll-up vs Hinged BAKFlip F1 vs Extang Trifecta 2.0 Hard folding vs Tri-fold BAKFlip F1 vs Retrax PRO XR Hard folding vs Retractable BAKFlip F1 vs UnderCover Classic Hard folding vs Hinged Extang Trifecta 2.0 vs Retrax PRO XR Tri-fold vs Retractable Extang Trifecta 2.0 vs UnderCover Classic Tri-fold vs Hinged Retrax PRO XR vs UnderCover Classic Retractable vs Hinged

Which cover type suits you? Browse the full product database Check what fits your truck

Comparing covers — frequently asked

How do you compare tonneau covers?

On three things that decide daily life with a cover — how well it resists a break-in, how well it seals against weather, and how completely it opens the bed — plus material, weight, warranty and price. Every cover in our database is rated on the same three-point scale, so the ratings are comparable across brands rather than being each manufacturer's own marketing.

Should I compare covers of the same type or different types?

Decide the type first, then compare within it. The gap between a hard folding cover and a soft roll-up is far larger than the gap between two good hard folding covers, so choosing the category is the decision that actually matters. The cross-type comparisons here exist for the cases where you are genuinely torn between two approaches.

Do these comparisons account for my truck?

No — they compare the covers themselves. Every cover is sold per truck and bed length, so once you have picked one, check it is made for your exact year, model and bed before ordering.